IPC International Community magazine an association member publication
Issue link: https://iconnect007.uberflip.com/i/1547617
30 I-CONNECT007 MAGAZINE I NOVEMBER 2026 become part of a much larger failure, but this deci- sion was not what ultimately sank us. The Turkey Hiding in Plain Sight During schematic development, the electrical en- gineer submitted a request for a library part rep- resenting the backplane processor, a BGA device that served as the brains of the entire assembly. The external library team created the part, and its qual- ity checker supposedly verified it. The component entered the library, and the design moved forward. I completed the PCB layout under tremendous schedule pressure. We conducted our electrical, mechanical, and layout reviews, and nothing obvious surfaced that would prevent us from releasing the design to fabrication. I performed a DFM review focused on fabrication, but I made a consequential decision: I skipped the assembly DFM analysis. Why? Because we were nearly out of time and money. The delivery window was about to pass us by. I had designed plenty of complex boards, trusted my own abilities, and believed we had done enough to move forward. I was very confident in our workmanship. I also assumed the outsourced library team had properly completed its work. Looking back, that was the critical mistake. I allowed confidence, schedule pressure, and assumptions about someone else's work to replace an independent verification step. The manufacturing files went out. A few weeks later, the assembled circuit cards arrived. The photos looked fantastic, and excitement was running high. We believed we were close to landing the contract that could secure the company's future. Then the phone rang. The Call I Will Never Forget I was at my day job when my electrical engineering partner called. I expected good news from the initial testing I knew was underway that morning. Instead, I heard panic. During power-up, the backplane pro- cessor was getting dangerously hot, and the circuit card was not functioning as expected. He tried an- other assembly, then another. All five exhibited the same problem. I found a private conference room and began working through the possibilities with him over the phone. I did not have my personal PCB layout workstation available, so I relied on him to review the design files while I opened and reviewed the processor manufacturer's datasheet. First, I asked him to verify the assembly orienta- tion. He checked, and the component was assem- bled correctly. That was when something clicked. I asked him to open the actual Gerber data and locate pin one in the PCB land pattern. Then I asked him to compare that location with pin one on the physical BGA package while I checked the manu- facturer's datasheet. As he described what he saw, and as I reviewed the BGA land pattern drawing in the datasheet, my stomach dropped: The land pattern had been created using the pin arrange- ment shown in the datasheet, but that drawing was explicitly labeled "VIEWED FROM BOTTOM SIDE." The library land pattern had been created incor- rectly, effectively reversing the pin mapping. I went silent for several seconds. My partner called out, "Steph? Steph? Are you there?" My response was not particularly professional, but it was certainly genuine. I realized we were not dealing with a fabri- cation defect or an assembly problem. We had a fundamental component library error that propa- gated through the entire design. The processor was the heart of the system. Correcting the problem would require a complete board respin, including rerouting, reassessing the power distribution network, and revisiting component placement. With the schedule already exhausted and funding nearly depleted, there was no realistic path to recovery. The contract opportu- nity was gone. The Discovery That Made It Worse As I reflected on what could have been, I ran an " The very analysis I had skipped because we supposedly did not have enough time could have identified the problem before fabrication and assembly."

