I-Connect007 Magazine

I007-Nov2026

IPC International Community magazine an association member publication

Issue link: https://iconnect007.uberflip.com/i/1547617

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 30 of 129

NOVEMBER 2026 I I-CONNECT007 MAGAZINE 31 assembly DFM analysis using Valor on the design over a holiday break. Within seconds (yes, seconds), the tool flagged the land-pattern problem. That result was devastating. The very analysis I had skipped because we supposedly did not have enough time could have identified the problem before fabrication and assembly. Instead, we had five nonfunctional assemblies and no time left to correct the design and meet the customer's dead- line. Had we run it, we would have caught the error before fabrication. That would have given us a fighting chance to recover; it was a small chance, but a chance nonetheless. The original error occurred during library creation, and the library team's quality check failed to catch it. But the mistake did not belong exclusively to the contractor. The incorrect land pattern passed through our design process, and I released the board without completing an assembly-focused verification that might have caught it. I still cannot say whether the library team created the land pattern from scratch, downloaded an existing part, or performed an inadequate review. I never learned the full story. What I do know is that our process allowed one unverified detail to become a catastrophic system-level failure. The startup eventually folded. My partners and I returned to our respective careers, and fortunately, we remain good friends. Every so often, we still joke about the retirement we might be enjoying if that project had succeeded—and the yacht we might have been sailing. I keep one of those circuit card assemblies on my shelf today. It is a physical reminder of what could have been and of what I learned. Why Every Designer Needs a Few Turkeys Experience does not make you immune to mistakes. Sometimes, experience makes you more vulnerable because repeated success can create confidence that is not supported by sufficient verification. I knew better than to skip an analysis, yet I convinced my- self that my experience, confidence, and our circum- stances justified doing so. That is the turkey I own. The lesson is not simply to double-check BGA pin assignments, although that is certainly part of it. It is to recognize that PCB design quality depends on a chain of verified decisions, from schematic capture and component-library creation through place- ment, routing, simulation, fabrication, assembly, and system validation. A failure at any link can compro- mise everything that follows. Today, as PCB designs become denser, faster, and more complex, we cannot rely on visual inspection or individual experience alone. We need disciplined library verification, independent design reviews, appropriate electrical simulation, and both fabrica- tion and assembly DFM analysis. Automated anal- ysis and simulation tools are especially valuable because they can identify problems that human reviewers overlook. But those tools must be inte- grated into the workflow, not treated as optional extras when the schedule gets tight. Most importantly, schedule pressure does not eliminate engineering risk. It merely changes how much risk we are willing to accept. When a critical verification step is skipped, the time saved may be insignificant compared with the cost of a failed build, a missed customer commitment, or a lost business. I would never wish that failed experience on another designer. But I would encourage every engineer, especially those early in their careers, to be honest about their mistakes, take ownership, and learn from them. A design failure can be an expen- sive teacher, but only if we are willing to examine our own decisions rather than blame everyone else. My biggest design turkey was not just a reversed BGA land pattern. It was believing that we could afford to skip verification because we were running out of time. Attention to detail is not a luxury, and verification and simulation are not overhead. They are essential parts of engineering. If that circuit card on my shelf can remind even one designer to run the analysis, challenge an assump- tion, or take the extra time to verify a critical library part, then some good has come from our failure. I-CONNECT007 Stephen V. Chavez is principal technical product marketing manager at Siemens EDA and chair of PCEA.

Articles in this issue

view archives of I-Connect007 Magazine - I007-Nov2026