IPC International Community magazine an association member publication
Issue link: https://iconnect007.uberflip.com/i/1547617
66 I-CONNECT007 MAGAZINE I NOVEMBER 2026 THE HIDDEN COST OF 'GOOD ENOUGH' PCBS BY M I C H A E L G L E AS O N , G R E E N S O U RC E FA B R I CAT I O N B U I LT F O R W H AT 'S N E XT I n PCB manufacturing, meet- ing specifications is fun- damental to delivering a reliable product. Drawings, material requirements, and defined tolerances provide the framework that allows designers and fabricators to work toward a common result. But as electronic sys- tems become more complex, there is value in looking beyond whether a board meets its docu- mented requirements and under- standing how those requirements relate to the performance of the finished product. "Good enough" is often used to describe a board that satisfies its specifications at an acceptable cost. In many applications, that is an entirely appro- priate standard. A prototype intended to demon- strate a concept will have different requirements from a board designed for long-term operation in a demanding environment. The opportunity lies in defining what "good enough" means for each appli- cation, identifying where additional precision adds meaningful value, and understanding how manu- facturing decisions influence performance over the life of the product. Understanding the Application Behind the Design A fabrication drawing communicates what needs to be manufactured, but it doesn't always provide the full context behind the design decisions. A particular tolerance may be important because of assembly requirements, while material prop- erties can influence electrical performance or thermal be- havior in ways that aren't im- mediately apparent from the drawing. Understanding the intended application helps fabricators recognize which characteristics require clos- er attention and where man- ufacturing alternatives may be worth considering. This is particularly relevant as designers work with higher frequencies, increasing power densi- ties, and more complex board architectures. The relationship between materials, geometry, and manufacturing processes becomes increasingly important as performance requirements evolve. At the same time, tighter tolerances and advanced materials aren't necessarily beneficial in every application. Applying them without a clear technical reason can introduce unnecessary manufacturing complexity and expense. The objective is to estab- lish requirements that reflect the actual needs of the product and support consistent, repeatable results. These considerations also depend on the accu- racy and completeness of the information provided to the fabricator. In practice, we regularly encounter fabrication drawings that reference specifications that haven't been provided, contain hole counts that don't match the design data, or lack clarity around via fill and cap plating requirements. These details are impor- tant because they establish the requirements the

