I-Connect007 Magazine

I007-Nov2026

IPC International Community magazine an association member publication

Issue link: https://iconnect007.uberflip.com/i/1547617

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 97 of 129

98 I-CONNECT007 MAGAZINE I NOVEMBER 2026 As soon as I heard the 30% slowdown in etch rate, I had that sinking feeling: I knew what the problem was and that it was caused by a mistake I had made. I had forgotten to consider that brass was around 70% copper and 30% zinc. With a regenerated cupric chloride bath and etching nothing but brass, the metallic composition of the etch bath soon matched the composition of the alloy being etched. Once the etch bath reached a 70% copper/30% zinc composition, the etch rate stabilized at 70% of that of a new bath. I had done the initial calculations based on our demonstration tests with an etch bath that had no zinc. Recalculating with zinc accounted for showed they needed four etch chambers to keep up with produc- tion once the bath stabilized, not three. Oops. Fortunately, the customer was very understanding about the whole thing, especially since we provided an additional etch chamber and installation at our expense, and we remained in their good graces for many years after. Also fortunate for me, my company culture did not require immediate dismissal for costly mistakes. They just wanted you to learn from those mistakes and not do it again. So, it was forgiven, but don't think for a minute it was forgotten. For years, I was reminded of that mistake, usually with great glee from the person doing the reminding. Eventually it was forgotten, but likely only because I'm the only one left with the company that still remembers that incident; everyone else has retired. There are some bene- fits to getting older, after all, in that you can outlive some of your mistakes. So, what did I take from this rather serious screw- up? First, we obviously sell equipment to etch metals other than copper, and the composition of those metals can have a major effect on the etch chemistry over time, especially if chemical regen- eration is involved. Double-check your etch param- eters before you calculate. Second, the customer's reaction to the mistake showed that it is better to come clean when you make a mistake and not try to weasel out of the blame. The customer was, of course, upset but our technical sales manager got me on a conference call with the customer and readily admitted that it was our mistake and we would rectify it at our cost. The customer immediately calmed down, and we were able to set a timeline for delivery and installa- tion of an extra etcher that was satisfactory for both companies without a lot of acrimony. The whole thing turned into a running joke between their process engineer and me for several years thereafter. Lastly, I learned that even I (gasp) could make a major mistake with all the best intentions in the world. I was pretty full of myself at that point in my career (I was in my mid-30s) and full of confidence that I had mastered the technology needed for my job. This was a wake-up call that knocked my confi- dence down a peg or two. In all honesty, this was a good thing at that point in time. Did that experience keep me from making more big mistakes during my career? Nope. Fortu- nately, most of them have been caught internally before escaping into the wild. Just last week I calcu- lated a system for a customer to do one panel a minute, although the specification clearly indicated that the desired production rate was two panels per minute. That one was caught by our sales engi- neer before the quote was made, so there was no problem, but it reminded me that I can still make serious errors despite all due diligence. I have also found that admitting my mistakes has made me more tolerant of others' honest mistakes, especially from new hires and interns. I think making mistakes is part of the learning process, especially when they make the same mistakes I did when I was learning the business. A calm approach to explaining those mistakes and showing them how to fix them is much more productive than ranting and raving. Careless or lazy mistakes are one thing, but if everyone is afraid of making mistakes, innovation stagnates and newer, more efficient approaches to business are never tried. I-CONNECT007 Don Ball is a process engineer at Chemcut. To read past columns or contact Ball, click here. T H E C H E M I CA L C O N N ECT I O N

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

view archives of I-Connect007 Magazine - I007-Nov2026