IPC International Community magazine an association member publication
Issue link: https://iconnect007.uberflip.com/i/1547617
88 I-CONNECT007 MAGAZINE I NOVEMBER 2026 electrical performance is required? What operating environment and product lifetime must the board support? These and other examples in the applica- tion may bring other requirements that must also be considered. The answers will define the perfor- mance window: the parameters, acceptable limits, and operating conditions that determine whether a material is suitable. For one product, thermal expansion and the ability to withstand assembly stresses may be the main concerns. 1 For another, dielectric properties and signal loss may be critical. 2 Moisture behaviour, insulation performance, and resistance to conductive anodic fila- ment (CAF) formation may also need attention. 3 The selection should reflect the application. A Tg value cannot describe all of this. Glass transition temperature is one property; it does not by itself establish long-term thermal endurance or the reliability of a finished board. We should also avoid copying every datasheet parameter into every specification. We need to iden- tify which parameters and limits matter for the prod- uct's performance and reliability, and why they are required. To compare materials properly, we also need to understand the test methods and conditions behind the values. Two dielectric-constant values measured at different frequencies or using different methods can give a misleading comparison. 2 IPC-4101 provides a recognised framework and important starting point for specifying laminate and prepreg, including the requirements in its specifica- tion sheets. 4 We still need to establish whether a candidate meets the requirements of our particular application and construction. Two materials can meet the same IPC-4101 slash sheet and still have different properties. Both may meet the specified limits, but that does not mean they are interchange- able in every PCB. My suggestion is to define the performance window first, then identify and qualify materials that meet the requirements of that performance window. If a particular brand is essential, document the reason. If alternatives are acceptable, document the conditions. Qualified by Whom, and for What? In my presentation, I discussed several routes to qualification: IPC Validation Services, NCAB, and third-party laboratories. 5 Each can help establish confidence in a material. To understand a material qualification, we need to know who carried out the evaluation, who accepted the evidence, and what the approval covers. Different organisations may be responsible for testing, reviewing the results and granting approval. A laboratory can produce the test evidence on which a customer or PCB supplier bases an approval. A qualifi- cation programme may combine testing with manufac- turing-site audits. A supplier may qualify both the mate- rial and the factory processes in which it will be used. Before approving the alternative for production, we need to check that the combined qualification evidence covers the requirements of the board we need to manufacture. What IPC Material Qualification Tells Us IPC Validation Services provides a formal route through the IPC-4101 Qualified Products List. The public listing identifies particular materials and specification sheets from suppliers including Arlon, Elite Material, Isola, TUC, and Ventec, with reports and dates. Unfortunately, the IPC-4101 QPL current- ly covers only a limited selection of laminates. 4 In my view, it cannot on its own provide the choices we need for the range of PCB applications we work with. If we restrict ourselves to listed materials, we may exclude suitable alternatives that have been qualified through other recognised routes. This makes qualification by PCB suppliers, manu- facturers, customers, and competent third-party laboratories an important part of qualified flexibility. The evidence must still match the application and the intended production process. IPC's qualification approach also addresses manufacturing sites and processes. Its published explanation describes onsite audits for the loca- tions manufacturing qualified products. 5 For a base- material listing, this means the facility manufacturing the laminate. It does not automatically establish that a downstream PCB factory has qualified the mate- rial for our board. The reports deserve attention too. For example, the linked Arlon 33N report is explicitly labelled "Self-Tested Data." 6 It describes the test evidence submitted. IPC is still the organisation Qualified Flexibility

