IPC International Community magazine an association member publication
Issue link: https://iconnect007.uberflip.com/i/1547617
90 I-CONNECT007 MAGAZINE I NOVEMBER 2026 must cover the actual PCB construction. Supplier qualification does not automatically autho- rise a material change in the customer's product. Any required customer approval must also be secured before the alternative is released for production. Qualification also needs continuing attention. Changes in materials, equipment, processing condi- tions, or product requirements can affect the basis of an earlier decision. The responsible organisation must decide whether the existing evidence still applies or whether further evaluation is needed. In my presentation, I also discussed capability approval, change control, audits and ongoing process monitoring. 8 They illustrate how an approval can be maintained throughout production. Other organisa- tions may structure the work differently, but they need to preserve the same connection between the approved conditions and what happens in the factory. For the customer, the useful question becomes who has approved this combination of material, construc- tion, and production facility, and what evidence supports that decision? With those answers, we can decide whether the alternative is ready to use. Make the Approval Usable Before the Shortage Consider a simple example: a six-layer industrial PCB. Material A is the established choice. Material B appears to satisfy the relevant requirements and is available sooner. If B has only been compared on paper, important work may still be needed. The team may still need to check the available cores and prepregs, confirm the stackup, review the factory's experience, obtain test evidence, and secure product approval. Now suppose that work was completed earlier. The alternative construction is documented, the supporting evidence is accepted, and the customer has approved its use under defined conditions. The supplier can then use the approved alternative, following the agreed requirements for notification and traceability. That is where the earlier qualifica- tion work pays off. For each alternative, the record should make clear what is approved, where it may be manu- factured, what evidence supports it, and which changes require further review. Engineering, quality, purchasing, and the supplier must have the same understanding. The phrase "or equivalent" leaves too much open unless equivalence and the approval process have been defined. A long list of approved materials also offers little flexibility if nobody knows which ones can be used for the product. To track the materials used, I recommend assigning a unique PCB article number to each approved material choice or to each defined combi- nation of materials. The specification linked to each article number should identify the exact laminate, prepreg, and solder mask, as applicable, together with the approved construction and production facilities. Production and delivery records must link that article number to the actual materials, mate- rial batches, and factory used. This gives us the freedom to use qualified alternatives while keeping a clear record of how each batch of boards was manufactured. We also need to ask whether the alternatives reduce our dependence on the material or capacity causing the delay. Two PCB factories waiting for the same constrained material may offer little relief. Even different laminate brands can share upstream constraints. Qualification establishes technical acceptability; supply-chain understanding tells us how much resilience the alternative adds. " This combination is what's most valuable: an identified material, a capable production facility, a controlled process, and evidence supporting their use together." Qualified Flexibility

